The Baratza Encore vs Timemore C2 comparison comes down to one fundamental question: is the convenience of electric grinding worth paying $120 more? Both are excellent burr grinders. Both produce consistently better coffee than blade grinders or pre-ground beans. The question is which one is right for your specific situation.
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
This comparison gives you the honest answer.
⭐ Quick Answer Choose the Timemore C2 if you’re on a budget, travel frequently, or want silent grinding. Choose the Baratza Encore if you want the convenience of electric grinding and brew at home daily.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Baratza Encore | Timemore C2 | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | ~$170 | ~$50 |
| Type | Electric | Manual |
| Burr size | 40mm | 38mm |
| Grind settings | 40 | 36 |
| Grind consistency | ✅ Excellent | Very good |
| Effort required | None — press a button | 30–60 seconds per cup |
| Portability | ❌ Not portable | ✅ Compact, travel-friendly |
| Noise | Moderate | ✅ Silent |
| Capacity | 8oz hopper | 25g per grind |
| Best for | Daily home brewing | Travel, budget, quiet grinding |
The Price Difference: Is It Justified?
The Baratza Encore costs $120 more than the Timemore C2. Here’s what that extra money buys you:
- Electric motor — press a button, walk away, coffee is ground in 10-15 seconds
- Slightly more consistent grind — the motor runs at a consistent speed unlike manual grinding
- Larger capacity — the 8oz hopper holds several days of beans
- 40 vs 36 settings — marginally more adjustment range
- Baratza support — repair service, replacement parts, long-term brand backing
What you don’t get for the extra money:
- Meaningfully better coffee in the cup for most brewing methods
- Better portability — the Encore is decidedly not portable
- Quieter operation — the Encore is significantly louder than the C2
- Better value per cup — the cost difference buys several years of specialty coffee beans
The honest truth is that for most brewing methods — French press, pour-over, AeroPress — the difference in cup quality between the Encore and C2 is small. The main difference is convenience.
Grind Consistency: How Much Does the Difference Matter?
The Baratza Encore produces a slightly more consistent grind than the Timemore C2. This is because the electric motor runs at a constant 450 RPM while manual grinding speed varies — and speed variation affects particle uniformity.
In practice, for French press, Chemex, and AeroPress the difference is minimal. Both grinders produce cups that are noticeably better than blade-ground or pre-ground coffee.
Where the consistency difference becomes more meaningful is pour-over — particularly V60 brewing where particle uniformity affects extraction control. Experienced V60 brewers may notice the Encore’s advantage here. Beginners typically won’t.
Verdict: The grind consistency difference matters more as your technique develops. For beginners, both grinders produce excellent results.
Convenience: The Real Differentiator
This is where the $120 price difference is actually felt day-to-day.
Baratza Encore morning routine: Fill the hopper once per week. Each morning: place your brew device under the chute, press ON, grind stops automatically, brew. Total active time: about 10 seconds.
Timemore C2 morning routine: Each morning: measure your beans, load them into the grinder, grind for 30-60 seconds, pour into your brew device, brew. Total active time: about 90 seconds including the grinding.
Neither is difficult. But if you’re half-asleep at 6am, a 10-second button press vs 90 seconds of active effort is a meaningful difference.
For people who enjoy the ritual of manual grinding — the tactile engagement, the quiet focus, the physical involvement in making their coffee — the C2’s extra effort is part of the appeal rather than a drawback. For people who just want coffee as efficiently as possible, the Encore is worth the premium.
How Each Grinder Feels to Use Day-to-Day
Baratza Encore daily experience: Turn the hopper to your preferred setting — a number you’ve already dialled in from previous brews. Place your French press or V60 under the chute. Press ON. Walk away. Come back to freshly ground coffee waiting for you. The Encore runs for about 10-15 seconds per cup and stops when the grounds bin is full or you press OFF. It’s almost entirely hands-off.
The noise is the main consideration — at about 60-65 decibels it’s similar to a food processor on medium. If you brew before others wake up this matters. Otherwise it’s background appliance noise.
Timemore C2 daily experience: Measure your beans and drop them into the top of the grinder. Hold the cylinder in your non-dominant hand and turn the handle with your dominant hand. The double bearing makes the grinding motion smooth — not jerky or effortful. Count roughly 30-60 turns depending on your grind size and serving. Remove the glass grounds catcher from the bottom, pour into your brew device.
The experience is quiet, physical, and more involved than electric grinding. Many coffee enthusiasts specifically prefer this — it’s a moment of calm focus rather than a passive wait. Others find it inconvenient. Only you know which camp you’re in.
Portability: The C2’s Strongest Advantage
The Timemore C2 is 52mm in diameter, weighs 430g, and fits in any bag. It requires no electricity. This makes it genuinely useful in contexts where the Baratza Encore simply can’t go:
- Hotel rooms and Airbnbs
- Camping and hiking
- Office use
- Travel of any kind
The Baratza Encore is a countertop appliance — it stays at home. If you travel frequently and want quality coffee on the road, the C2 is the only sensible choice between the two.
Noise: A Meaningful Practical Difference
The Baratza Encore runs at 60-65 decibels — moderately loud. The Timemore C2 is essentially silent.
This matters more than most people expect:
- Early morning brewing before others wake up
- Apartment living with thin walls
- Offices where you want to be considerate
- Anyone who values a quiet morning routine
If silence matters to you, the C2 has a clear advantage.
What About Other Options?
The Encore and C2 are the two most recommended grinders at their respective price points — but they’re not the only options worth knowing about.
OXO Brew Conical Burr Grinder (~$100) — electric, sits between the two in price. Slightly less consistent than the Encore but more convenient than the C2. A strong middle-ground option.
Timemore C3S (~$75) — the upgraded Timemore manual grinder with a larger capacity and improved burrs. Worth considering if you want more capacity than the C2 without going electric.
JavaPresse Manual Grinder (~$30) — the budget option below the C2. Decent for occasional use but not recommended for daily brewing — the grind consistency is noticeably worse than the Timemore.
For most beginners the choice is straightforward: start with the Timemore C2 if budget or portability is a priority, upgrade to the Baratza Encore when you’re ready to invest in electric convenience. The OXO is worth considering as a middle-ground option.
See our Best Beginner Coffee Grinders Under $150 guide for a broader comparison.
Who Should Buy Each
Choose the Timemore C2 if:
- Budget is a priority — $50 vs $170 is a significant difference
- You travel frequently and want quality coffee on the road
- You brew for one person and don’t mind 60 seconds of grinding
- You want silent grinding
- You want to try fresh grinding before committing to an electric grinder
- You enjoy a more hands-on, involved morning coffee routine
Choose the Baratza Encore if:
- You brew at home daily and want electric convenience
- You regularly brew for two or more people
- You want the best entry-level electric burr grinder available
- Noise isn’t a significant concern
- You’re ready to invest in a grinder that will last 10+ years
Winner by Category
Our Recommendations
For budget buyers and travellers: 👉 Timemore C2 (~$50) 👉 Timemore C2S (~$55) — full metal upgrade
For daily home brewers who want electric convenience: 👉 Baratza Encore Black (~$170) 👉 Baratza Encore White (~$170)
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Baratza Encore worth $120 more than the Timemore C2? For daily home brewers who want electric convenience — yes. The hands-off grinding experience and slightly better consistency justify the premium for most people who brew at home every day. For budget buyers, travellers, or anyone happy to grind manually, the C2 produces excellent coffee at a third of the price.
Does the Baratza Encore make noticeably better coffee than the Timemore C2? For most brewing methods and most beginners — not noticeably. Both produce significantly better coffee than blade grinders or pre-ground beans. The Encore’s consistency advantage becomes more meaningful as your technique develops, particularly for pour-over brewing.
Can I use the Timemore C2 for pour-over? Yes — it’s one of the C2’s strongest use cases. The medium-fine settings produce consistent grounds that give you good control over your V60 or Chemex extraction. Many pour-over enthusiasts specifically choose manual grinders like the C2.
Which grinder should I start with as a complete beginner? If budget is a concern — start with the Timemore C2. If budget isn’t a concern and you want convenience — start with the Baratza Encore. Both will significantly improve your coffee over pre-ground beans.
Can I upgrade from the Timemore C2 to the Baratza Encore later? Yes — many people start with the C2 and upgrade to the Encore once they’re brewing daily and want electric convenience. The C2 doesn’t become useless after upgrading — it makes an excellent travel grinder.
Continue Learning
- Baratza Encore Review → full review of the electric option
- Timemore C2 Review → full review of the manual option
- Best Beginner Coffee Grinders Under $150 → broader guide covering more grinder options at every price point
- Hario V60 Review → the most popular pour-over dripper to pair with either grinder
- Best French Press for Beginners → the most forgiving brewing method to pair with a new grinder
- Best Coffee Beans for Beginners → freshly ground beans make the biggest difference to your cup